Take care what you say Rosie
He may just be saving them up for you way way in the future.
I have a special thing with my grandson in France (it works wonders especially if he's not been doing what he's told) We call it the 5 kisses remedy.
It's only ever done with me. We kiss each other first on the forehead then on the nose then on each cheek and finally a big smacker on the mouth. By the time its finished he's laughing and then he says sorry and does what he should have done in the first place.
Wonder if I should try that with the dogs???